UX case study · A/B testing

Improving price display through clarity

Findhotel showed travellers one price when they picked a room and asked for a different one at checkout. I broke the price down while people were still choosing, and a five-week A/B test measured whether a clearer price sells more rooms.

5wks
The test ran
50/50
Traffic, split evenly
+3.5%
Conversion, outside the United States
Client
Role UX Designer, sole designer on price display
Team 1 UX designer, 1 product owner, 1 data scientist, 1 copywriter, an external translation agency, a scrum team
Timeline September 2020 to January 2021: the benchmark in September, the design from November
Platform The booking funnel, on desktop and mobile web
Tools Figma, Zeplin, FullStory
A hotel price broken into a nightly rate, taxes and fees, local tax, a resort fee, other local taxes, a total, a saving, and what is paid now against what is paid at the property

The key panel. Every line under the room rate used to appear for the first time at checkout.

Problem

A price that grew on the way to the till

Findhotel is a smaller player in hotel booking. It works the local markets the biggest platforms tend to leave alone, and much of what it sells is distress inventory: rooms a hotel expects not to sell, and cannot list itself without the big sites ranking it lower.

That stock sells on price, and our own booking flow was weakening that argument. The price shown when someone chose a room was not the price they were asked for two screens later. Our data showed a large drop-off, concentrated on the checkout page.

The gap was widest for travellers outside the United States, because that is where the extra charges are: a city tax collected by the municipality, a resort fee collected by the hotel, other local charges that change from place to place. None of it was hidden on purpose. It just appeared late, unnamed and all at once.

For once, the business and the traveller wanted the same thing. The business wanted a higher conversion rate. I wanted travellers to answer what am I paying for, and why? without opening a second tab.

Deal details, the one screen in the funnel whose entire job is to answer that question.

Goals

What the work had to do

Say the number early
Show what a stay really costs while people are still choosing, not after they have committed.
Name every charge
A fee with a name can be understood and possibly forgiven. An unlabelled sum at the end can only be resented.
Roll it out without betting the funnel
Reach every market eventually, and be able to stop after the first one if the numbers went the wrong way.

We designed the first release for American travellers arriving from Google hotel ads on the room selection page: the largest and most important group on the site. The plan was to start with the biggest group and then move to smaller markets, so each later step carried less risk.

Our team owned the room selection page and everything after it. The search and landing pages belonged to other teams, so travellers formed their idea of the price on a screen we could not change.

Deep dive

The limits of the research

Desk research and one A/B test, no lab sessions

There was no budget for moderated testing. A few customers were called, but to hear what they already disliked about the booking, not to try a prototype. So the research here is a benchmark and a set of session recordings, not a study.

Two screens, then more
It started on room selection and payment. As evidence arrived it reached deal details, the confirmation screen, confirmation emails and booking management.
Desk research, not a lab
Eight platforms in seven countries, worked through by hand. No moderated sessions.
Five weeks of live traffic
One A/B test, split evenly, long enough to survive a weekend pattern and short enough to act on.
Deep dive

Who did what

Team map

The product owner brought the business case and set the priorities. The data scientist supplied the numbers the decisions rested on and designed the A/B tests that measured them. A copywriter owned the wording of every label. A third-party agency translated that wording into the languages the site runs in.

Everything between the problem and the handover was mine: the benchmark, the ideation and scoping sessions, the wireframes and the prototype, the guerrilla tests, the development plan, the high-fidelity screens, the manual testing before release, the watching afterwards, and the write-up that let anybody else in the company follow what had changed.

The team Search listing team Other teams PD PO DES Dev PO DES Dev PO DS DES Dev Dev FE The team Search team Other teams PD PO DES Dev PO DES Dev PO DS DES Dev Dev FE

Inside the box, the product owner, the data scientist and the developers worked alongside me, one of the developers mainly on the front end. There was no scrum master. The product owner and I answered to the product director. Around the box are the other teams, built the same way: a designer, a product owner and developers. I worked mostly with their designers, and with the designer of the Search listing team on keeping the customer journey aligned. Its product owner and I communicated indirectly.

Process

How it was made

The work ran in loops, and each pass leaned on whichever step the product needed most at the time. The benchmark was the exception: I did it thoroughly once and went back to it afterwards.

01

What other booking sites do

It started as one question with a complex answer: what do other platforms include in the nightly price?

Vendor includes general tax in nightly rate?

Yes, from the search results onwards

No, only at checkout

Names the base rate and the total together

Vendor includes local tax in nightly rate?

Yes, from the search results onwards

No, only at checkout

Names the base rate and the total together

Two questions, asked at every platform

Does the nightly rate include the general tax, the sales tax the platform itself collects?

Does the nightly rate include the local tax, the city or tourist tax the destination collects?

  • Included from the start
  • Revealed in checkout
  • Inconsistent
  • Stated separately

Two searches, one hotel

FindHotel
Local General
Market Incl.: Included from the start Held: Revealed in checkout Mix: Inconsistent Split: Stated separately Incl.: Included from the start Held: Revealed in checkout Mix: Inconsistent Split: Stated separately
GermanyDEU: Germany Included from the startNot: Revealed in checkoutNot: InconsistentNot: Stated separately Included from the startNot: Revealed in checkoutNot: InconsistentNot: Stated separately
NetherlandsNLD: Netherlands Included from the startNot: Revealed in checkoutNot: InconsistentNot: Stated separately Included from the startNot: Revealed in checkoutNot: InconsistentNot: Stated separately
United KingdomGBR: United Kingdom Included from the startNot: Revealed in checkoutNot: InconsistentNot: Stated separately Included from the startNot: Revealed in checkoutNot: InconsistentNot: Stated separately
AustraliaAUS: Australia Included from the startNot: Revealed in checkoutNot: InconsistentNot: Stated separately Included from the startNot: Revealed in checkoutNot: InconsistentNot: Stated separately
BelarusBLR: Belarus Included from the startNot: Revealed in checkoutNot: InconsistentNot: Stated separately Included from the startNot: Revealed in checkoutNot: InconsistentNot: Stated separately
IndonesiaIDN: Indonesia Included from the startNot: Revealed in checkoutNot: InconsistentNot: Stated separately Included from the startNot: Revealed in checkoutNot: InconsistentNot: Stated separately
IsraelISR: Israel Included from the startNot: Revealed in checkoutNot: InconsistentNot: Stated separately Included from the startNot: Revealed in checkoutNot: InconsistentNot: Stated separately
Expedia
Local General
Market Incl.: Included from the start Held: Revealed in checkout Mix: Inconsistent Split: Stated separately Incl.: Included from the start Held: Revealed in checkout Mix: Inconsistent Split: Stated separately
GermanyDEU: Germany Included from the startNot: Revealed in checkoutNot: InconsistentStated separately Included from the startNot: Revealed in checkoutNot: InconsistentStated separately
NetherlandsNLD: Netherlands Included from the startNot: Revealed in checkoutNot: InconsistentStated separately Included from the startNot: Revealed in checkoutNot: InconsistentStated separately
United KingdomGBR: United Kingdom Included from the startNot: Revealed in checkoutNot: InconsistentStated separately Included from the startNot: Revealed in checkoutNot: InconsistentStated separately
AustraliaAUS: Australia Included from the startNot: Revealed in checkoutNot: InconsistentStated separately Included from the startNot: Revealed in checkoutNot: InconsistentStated separately
BelarusBLR: Belarus Included from the startNot: Revealed in checkoutNot: InconsistentStated separately Included from the startNot: Revealed in checkoutNot: InconsistentStated separately
IndonesiaIDN: Indonesia Included from the startNot: Revealed in checkoutNot: InconsistentStated separately Included from the startNot: Revealed in checkoutNot: InconsistentStated separately
IsraelISR: Israel Included from the startNot: Revealed in checkoutNot: InconsistentStated separately Included from the startNot: Revealed in checkoutNot: InconsistentStated separately
Airbnb
Local General
Market Incl.: Included from the start Held: Revealed in checkout Mix: Inconsistent Split: Stated separately Incl.: Included from the start Held: Revealed in checkout Mix: Inconsistent Split: Stated separately
GermanyDEU: Germany Included from the startNot: Revealed in checkoutNot: InconsistentStated separately Included from the startNot: Revealed in checkoutNot: InconsistentStated separately
NetherlandsNLD: Netherlands Included from the startNot: Revealed in checkoutNot: InconsistentStated separately Included from the startNot: Revealed in checkoutNot: InconsistentStated separately
United KingdomGBR: United Kingdom Included from the startNot: Revealed in checkoutNot: InconsistentStated separately Included from the startNot: Revealed in checkoutNot: InconsistentStated separately
AustraliaAUS: Australia Included from the startNot: Revealed in checkoutNot: InconsistentStated separately Included from the startNot: Revealed in checkoutNot: InconsistentStated separately
BelarusBLR: Belarus Included from the startNot: Revealed in checkoutNot: InconsistentStated separately Included from the startNot: Revealed in checkoutNot: InconsistentStated separately
IndonesiaIDN: Indonesia Not recorded Not: Included from the startRevealed in checkoutNot: InconsistentNot: Stated separately
IsraelISR: Israel Included from the startNot: Revealed in checkoutNot: InconsistentStated separately Included from the startNot: Revealed in checkoutNot: InconsistentStated separately
Deep dive

More platforms

Agoda, Booking, Kayak, Skyscanner, TripAdvisor
Agoda
Local General
Market Incl.: Included from the start Held: Revealed in checkout Mix: Inconsistent Split: Stated separately Incl.: Included from the start Held: Revealed in checkout Mix: Inconsistent Split: Stated separately
GermanyDEU: Germany Included from the startNot: Revealed in checkoutNot: InconsistentNot: Stated separately Included from the startNot: Revealed in checkoutNot: InconsistentNot: Stated separately
NetherlandsNLD: Netherlands Included from the startNot: Revealed in checkoutNot: InconsistentNot: Stated separately Included from the startNot: Revealed in checkoutNot: InconsistentNot: Stated separately
United KingdomGBR: United Kingdom *Included from the startNot: Revealed in checkoutNot: InconsistentNot: Stated separately *Included from the startNot: Revealed in checkoutNot: InconsistentNot: Stated separately
AustraliaAUS: Australia *Included from the startNot: Revealed in checkoutNot: InconsistentNot: Stated separately *Included from the startNot: Revealed in checkoutNot: InconsistentNot: Stated separately
BelarusBLR: Belarus Not: Included from the start*Revealed in checkoutNot: InconsistentNot: Stated separately Not: Included from the start*Revealed in checkoutNot: InconsistentNot: Stated separately
IndonesiaIDN: Indonesia Not: Included from the start*Revealed in checkoutNot: InconsistentNot: Stated separately Not: Included from the start*Revealed in checkoutNot: InconsistentNot: Stated separately
IsraelISR: Israel Not: Included from the start*Revealed in checkoutNot: InconsistentNot: Stated separately Not: Included from the start*Revealed in checkoutNot: InconsistentNot: Stated separately
Booking.com
Local General
Market Incl.: Included from the start Held: Revealed in checkout Mix: Inconsistent Split: Stated separately Incl.: Included from the start Held: Revealed in checkout Mix: Inconsistent Split: Stated separately
GermanyDEU: Germany Included from the startNot: Revealed in checkoutNot: InconsistentNot: Stated separately Included from the startNot: Revealed in checkoutNot: InconsistentNot: Stated separately
NetherlandsNLD: Netherlands Included from the startNot: Revealed in checkoutNot: InconsistentNot: Stated separately Included from the startNot: Revealed in checkoutNot: InconsistentNot: Stated separately
United KingdomGBR: United Kingdom Included from the startNot: Revealed in checkoutNot: InconsistentNot: Stated separately Included from the startNot: Revealed in checkoutNot: InconsistentNot: Stated separately
AustraliaAUS: Australia Not: Included from the startRevealed in checkoutNot: InconsistentNot: Stated separately Included from the startNot: Revealed in checkoutNot: InconsistentNot: Stated separately
BelarusBLR: Belarus Not: Included from the startRevealed in checkoutNot: InconsistentNot: Stated separately Included from the startNot: Revealed in checkoutNot: InconsistentNot: Stated separately
IndonesiaIDN: Indonesia Included from the startNot: Revealed in checkoutNot: InconsistentNot: Stated separately Included from the startNot: Revealed in checkoutNot: InconsistentNot: Stated separately
IsraelISR: Israel Not: Included from the startRevealed in checkoutNot: InconsistentNot: Stated separately Included from the startNot: Revealed in checkoutNot: InconsistentNot: Stated separately
KAYAK
Local General
Market Incl.: Included from the start Held: Revealed in checkout Mix: Inconsistent Split: Stated separately Incl.: Included from the start Held: Revealed in checkout Mix: Inconsistent Split: Stated separately
GermanyDEU: Germany Included from the startNot: Revealed in checkoutNot: InconsistentNot: Stated separately Included from the startNot: Revealed in checkoutNot: InconsistentNot: Stated separately
NetherlandsNLD: Netherlands Included from the startNot: Revealed in checkoutNot: InconsistentNot: Stated separately Included from the startNot: Revealed in checkoutNot: InconsistentNot: Stated separately
United KingdomGBR: United Kingdom Included from the startNot: Revealed in checkoutNot: InconsistentNot: Stated separately Included from the startNot: Revealed in checkoutNot: InconsistentNot: Stated separately
AustraliaAUS: Australia Included from the startNot: Revealed in checkoutNot: InconsistentNot: Stated separately Not: Included from the startNot: Revealed in checkoutInconsistentNot: Stated separately
BelarusBLR: Belarus Included from the startNot: Revealed in checkoutNot: InconsistentNot: Stated separately Not: Included from the startNot: Revealed in checkoutInconsistentNot: Stated separately
IndonesiaIDN: Indonesia Included from the startNot: Revealed in checkoutNot: InconsistentNot: Stated separately Not: Included from the startNot: Revealed in checkoutInconsistentNot: Stated separately
IsraelISR: Israel Included from the startNot: Revealed in checkoutNot: InconsistentNot: Stated separately Included from the startNot: Revealed in checkoutNot: InconsistentNot: Stated separately
Skyscanner
Local General
Market Incl.: Included from the start Held: Revealed in checkout Mix: Inconsistent Split: Stated separately Incl.: Included from the start Held: Revealed in checkout Mix: Inconsistent Split: Stated separately
GermanyDEU: Germany Included from the startNot: Revealed in checkoutNot: InconsistentNot: Stated separately Included from the startNot: Revealed in checkoutNot: InconsistentNot: Stated separately
NetherlandsNLD: Netherlands Included from the startNot: Revealed in checkoutNot: InconsistentNot: Stated separately Included from the startNot: Revealed in checkoutNot: InconsistentNot: Stated separately
United KingdomGBR: United Kingdom *Included from the startNot: Revealed in checkoutNot: InconsistentNot: Stated separately *Included from the startNot: Revealed in checkoutNot: InconsistentNot: Stated separately
AustraliaAUS: Australia Not: Included from the startNot: Revealed in checkoutInconsistentNot: Stated separately Not: Included from the startNot: Revealed in checkoutInconsistentNot: Stated separately
BelarusBLR: Belarus Not: Included from the startNot: Revealed in checkoutInconsistentNot: Stated separately Not: Included from the startNot: Revealed in checkoutInconsistentNot: Stated separately
IndonesiaIDN: Indonesia Not: Included from the startNot: Revealed in checkoutInconsistentNot: Stated separately Not: Included from the startNot: Revealed in checkoutInconsistentNot: Stated separately
IsraelISR: Israel Not: Included from the startNot: Revealed in checkoutInconsistentNot: Stated separately Not: Included from the startNot: Revealed in checkoutInconsistentNot: Stated separately
TripAdvisor
Local General
Market Incl.: Included from the start Held: Revealed in checkout Mix: Inconsistent Split: Stated separately Incl.: Included from the start Held: Revealed in checkout Mix: Inconsistent Split: Stated separately
GermanyDEU: Germany Included from the startNot: Revealed in checkoutNot: InconsistentNot: Stated separately Included from the startNot: Revealed in checkoutNot: InconsistentNot: Stated separately
NetherlandsNLD: Netherlands Not: Included from the startRevealed in checkoutNot: InconsistentNot: Stated separately Not: Included from the startRevealed in checkoutNot: InconsistentNot: Stated separately
United KingdomGBR: United Kingdom *Included from the startNot: Revealed in checkoutNot: InconsistentNot: Stated separately *Included from the startNot: Revealed in checkoutNot: InconsistentNot: Stated separately
AustraliaAUS: Australia Not: Included from the startRevealed in checkoutNot: InconsistentNot: Stated separately Not: Included from the startRevealed in checkoutNot: InconsistentNot: Stated separately
BelarusBLR: Belarus Did not appear to sell into Belarus that month.
IndonesiaIDN: Indonesia Not: Included from the startRevealed in checkoutNot: InconsistentNot: Stated separately Not: Included from the startRevealed in checkoutNot: InconsistentNot: Stated separately
IsraelISR: Israel Not: Included from the start*Revealed in checkoutNot: InconsistentNot: Stated separately Not: Included from the start*Revealed in checkoutNot: InconsistentNot: Stated separately

* Added the nights together only at checkout: search and room selection still quoted them one at a time.

Only Airbnb and Expedia, the starred rows, answered both questions the same way in every market. Their answer was neither yes nor no: they show the base rate and the total together. Everyone else, Findhotel included, picked one number and hoped it suited the country.

Deep dive

Every platform's prices, room by room

Table

How each platform showed its prices in September 2020, for one room and for several.

Single room
Multiple rooms
Single room
Price details
1 room x 1 night$123.37
You saved 20% ⓘ
Taxes and fees ⓘ$11.10
Local taxPayable at property$7.06
Local taxPayable at property$8.64
Total$150.17
Pay now$134.47
Pay at property$15.70

Rates are quoted in US dollars. Taxes and/or property imposed fees of $15.70 will be collected by the property in the local currency (€13.34). Taxes and/or fees due at the property are based on current exchange rates, which may vary at time of travel.

Multiple rooms
Price details
2 rooms x 1 night$663.44
🏷 You saved 30% ⓘ
Taxes and fees ⓘ$59.72
Local taxPayable at property$14.12
Local taxPayable at property$46.44
Total$783.72
Pay now$723.16
Pay at property$60.56

Rates are quoted in US dollars. Taxes and/or property imposed fees of $60.56 will be collected by the property in the local currency (€51.47). Taxes and/or fees due at the property are based on current exchange rates, which may vary at time of travel.

Single room
Your Genius Price Summary
Small Double RoomIncludes Genius benefit€ 58.83
9 % VAT€ 5.29
Tourism fee€ 3
7 % City tax€ 4.12
Price € 71.24 (for 1 guest)
Multiple rooms
Check-in
Thu 22 Oct 2020
Check-out
Fri 23 Oct 2020
1 night, 2 roomsChange dates

FREE cancellation before 23:59 on 20 October 2020

2 rooms€ 249.36
9 % VAT€ 22.44
Tourism fee€ 12
7 % City tax€ 17.46
Total price due at stay:€ 301.26
Now you’ll pay€ 0

No payment needed now. You’ll pay at the property.

Single room
Original price (1 room x 1 night)€ 413.76
Price (1 room x 1 night)€ 60.00
Booking feesFREE
Price ⓘ€ 60.00

Included in price: Hotel tax and service fees € 4.95

Not included in price (collected by the property): City Tax € 3.85

We price match. Find it for less, and we’ll match it! ⓘ

YOU SAVED € 353.76 ON THIS BOOKING!

Multiple rooms

14% OFF TODAY

Original price (2 rooms x 1 night)€ 139.36
Our price€ 135.00
✓ 24HOURSALE Coupon applied-€ 15.96
Price (2 rooms x 1 night)€ 119.04
Booking feesFREE
Price ⓘ€ 119.04

Included in price: VAT 9%

Not included in price (collected by the property): City Tax € 12.50

We price match. Find it for less, and we’ll match it! ⓘ

YOU SAVED € 15.96 ON THIS BOOKING!

Single room
1 night£205.25
Taxes and fees£36.06
Value Added Tax£18.66
Local tax (Pay on arrival)£17.40
Total£241.31
Pay now £223.91
Pay on arrival £17.40 (19.22 EUR) ⓘ
The price shown in GBP is for reference only and it may change. Payment at check-in must be in EUR. Reference exchange rate: 1.00 GBP=1.1046028974 EUR

🚗 Free cancellation

Multiple rooms
Single room
Budget Twin Room Shared Bathroom
📅 Tue, 10/20 - Wed, 10/21Change Dates
Nightly Rate€55.05
Rooms1
Nights1
Guests2
Subtotal€55.05
Taxes and Fees€14.80
Total:€69.85

Book now. Pay later when you stay.

Free Cancellation until Oct 18, 2020 ⓘ

Multiple rooms
Standaard driepersoonskamer, 3 eenpersoonsbedden
📅 Wed, 10/21 - Thu, 10/22Change Dates
Nightly Rate€57.80
Rooms2
Nights1
Adults4
Children1
Subtotal€115.60
Taxes and Fees€30.50
Total:€146.10

Non Refundable ⓘ

Single room
Summary

1 room, 2 guests, 2 nights
Fri 09-11-2020 - Sun 09-13-2020


Charges
Standard Double Room$281.39
Taxes, Fees & Surcharges$25.31
City taxPayable at hotel.$33.86
Total ⓘ$340.56
€288.70
Multiple rooms
Summary

2 rooms, 4 guests, 2 nights
Fri 09-11-2020 - Sun 09-13-2020


Charges
Standard Queen Room$389.61
Taxes, Fees & Surcharges$35.05
City taxPayable at hotel.$55.59
Total ⓘ$480.25
€407.12
Single room
Price
Room Subtotal:USD 105.60
USD 88.00

(US$44.00/night x 2 nights)

Taxes & Fees:USD 19.97
Total Price:USD 107.97
You Saved:USD 17.60
Cancellation Policy:
Learn more
Refundable until Oct 02, 2020
Promo Code ▾ Credits ▾
Multiple rooms
1 Night, 4 GuestsChange Dates
☐ VIP Package for $2.99 ⓘ Included: Free upgrade call, 24hr Concierge, Priority Support line

Price
Room Subtotal:USD 87.92
USD 79.29

(US$79.29/night x 1 night)

Tips:USD 1.00
Taxes & Fees:USD 14.27
Total Price:USD 94.56
You Saved:USD 8.63
Tip $1 for saving you $8.63? ⓘ Your support helps us deliver the best in hotel deals.
$1
No Tip$10
Cancellation Policy:
Learn more
Non Refundable
Single room
1 room x 1 night€61.98
Taxes & fees€5.26
VAT€5.26
Special Discount- €3.60
Subtotal (Pay to Trip.com)€63.64

Additional Fees (Pay at Hotel)

City Tax€4.09
City Fee€6.00
Total€73.73

Taxes and fees may vary upon arrival

Multiple rooms
Check-in: Tue, Oct 13
Check-out: Wed, Oct 14
1 night
Rooms: 2›
Prepay Online €138.04›

Taxes due at hotel: ≈ €53.72


×Price Summary

Prepay Online
An online prepayment of €138.04 is required to book this room.

Included in the price: Breakfast not included

2 rooms x 1 night€140.63
Taxes & fees ⓘ€11.41
Silver Tier Deal-€14
Subtotal (Pay to Trip.com)approx. €138.04
Additional Fees (Pay at Hotel)€53.72

other tax and fee

Totalapprox. €191.76
(Local currency: US$225.58)

Taxes and fees may vary upon arrival

Receive after stay:★ 130

130 Trip Coins = €1.11

Best stay with free cancellation

Single room
Summary
🔒 Price Guarantee
Friday, September 11, 202070,18€
Taxes and fees6,31€
City tax10,91€
Includes Your Secret Price: You’re saving 9% as a member
Total price87,40€

for 1 room, 2 guests, 1 night
including taxes and fees

Payment schedule
Due now76,49€
Due at property10,91€

📈 This price may increase if you book later.

Multiple rooms
Summary
🔒 Price Guarantee
Average nightly rate$204.14 CAD

Superior Twin Room 👤👤

Free cancellation

Wednesday, October 14, 2020$189.13 CAD

Executive Double Room 👤👤👤

Free cancellation

Wednesday, October 14, 2020$219.15 CAD
Taxes and fees$36.74 CAD
City tax$47.28 CAD
Includes Your Secret Price:
Total price$492.30 CAD*

for 2 rooms, 5 guests, 1 night
including taxes and fees

Payment schedule
Due now$445.02 CAD
Due at property$47.28 CAD
(30,34€)

*Prices are quoted in CAD based on the current exchange rate. The amount due at the property is payable in EUR.

📈 This price may increase if you book later.

Deep dive

The raw captures, country by country

Seven screenshots

These seven captures are what the matrix was read from: each country's results in one pass, as the sites looked in September 2020.

02

Designing a price you can read

I ran the ideation sessions with the benchmark on the table. Seeing what eight competitors did with the same booking gave the team real examples to discuss instead of opinions.

Scoping followed each session, with the product owner and the data scientist. Two questions, always in this order: "What would the right answer look like if nothing were in the way of development?", and "What is the smallest piece we could develop to put in real traffic?". The gap between those two answers made the roadmap.

A breakdown that appears only at the moment of payment comes too late to help anyone choose. So the same lines had to carry on after payment: onto the confirmation screen and into the email that follows. The confirmation screen carries the same breakdown as checkout, plus two new lines: what has been paid, and what the property will still collect.

The confirmation screen, wireframed. The currency placeholders are there because the breakdown had to work in every market.

Then I drew the final screens with Findhotel's style guide and component library, so developers assembled known parts instead of interpreting a picture. The key desktop and mobile screens went to the developers in Zeplin.

Deep dive

Every screen the price touches

Flow diagram

The wireframes became a clickable prototype, kept rough on purpose. It was for stakeholders and anyone in the company with an interest in the outcome, and a rough screen keeps the conversation on the price instead of the polish.

Then I tested it in the corridor with whoever was available. That catches the obvious problems and raises the questions that need real research: what happens when the traveller's currency is not the hotel's, across several rooms, or when the fee is bigger than the room.

Search
Browsing hotels

Silver cloud hotel at Seattle Stadium ★★★

Pioneer Square · 1.5km from city centre

€264
€320
€352

The Belltown Inn ★★

Belltown · 1.3km from city centre

€92
€103
€104
Room selection
Selecting a room

Silver cloud hotel at Seattle Stadium ★★★

1046 1st Avenue South, Pioneer Square, Seattle

You found the best deal33% off

Compared with 2 other sites

· 2 Queen bedroom€320
· King room€352

Standard room
2 guests max

€264

What fees does this deal have?

Just a local tax
Price details33% off
2 nights x 3 rooms
€165.16
Taxes and fees
€31.12
Local tax
€1.00
Total
€197.28
Pay now€196.28
Pay at property€1.00
Just a resort fee
Price details33% off
2 nights x 3 rooms
€165.16
Taxes and fees
€31.12
Resort fee
€148.04
Total
€344.32
Pay now€196.28
Pay at property€148.04
Resort fee, local tax, and other fees
Price details33% off
2 nights x 3 rooms
€165.16
Taxes and fees
€31.12
Local tax
€1.00
Resort fee
€148.04
Other local taxes and fees
€67.40
Total
€412.72
Pay now€196.28
Pay at property€216.44

What’s the currency situation?

Nothing extra is shown: the traveller's own currency already matches the hotel's.

Local taxes or resort fees will be collected by the property in the local currency.
The price is converted to show the approximate cost in AUD. You will pay now in EUR.
No pay-at-property fees
Price details33% off
2 nights x 3 rooms
€165.16
Taxes and fees
€31.12
Total
€196.28
Pay now€196.28
Just other local taxes and fees
Price details33% off
2 nights x 3 rooms
€165.16
Taxes and fees
€31.12
Other local taxes and fees
€67.40
Total
€263.68
Pay now€196.28
Pay at property€67.40
Checkout
Checking out

Personal details

First name
Last name
Email address

Payment

Card number
Expiration · Security code
Confirm payment
Price details33% off
2 nights x 3 rooms
€165.16
Taxes and fees
€31.12
Local tax
€1.00
Resort fee
€148.04
Other local taxes and fees
€67.40
Total
€412.72
Pay now€196.28
Pay at property€216.44

The same fee-display rule from Deal details carries through here.

Confirmation
Success

How likely are you to recommend FindHotel?

012345678910

Congratulations!

Your booking has been confirmed

675919442573866
Booking confirmation email

· via email

Hi {FirstName},
Your booking is confirmed.

Booking ID: 675919442573866

Manage booking
Booking management
Booking overview

Silver cloud hotel at Seattle Stadium

  • Check-in · Sep 17, 2020
  • Check-out · Sep 19, 2020
  • Room 1: Standard Room · 2 adults
  • Room 2: Standard Room · 2 adults, 1 child
Price details33% off
2 nights x 3 rooms
€165.16
Taxes and fees
€31.12
Local tax
€1.00
Resort fee
€148.04
Other local taxes and fees
€67.40
Total
€412.72
Pay now€196.28
Pay at property€216.44

The same fee-display rule from Deal details carries through here.

Free cancellation before Sep 14, 2020. There is a €34 fee for cancelling after this date.

Cancel booking
Cancellation
Confirm cancellation

Cancel this booking?

This discounted rate is non-refundable. You will not be refunded any of the payment already made.

Price details33% off
2 nights x 3 rooms
€165.16
Taxes and fees
€31.12
Local tax
€1.00
Resort fee
€148.04
Other local taxes and fees
€67.40
Total
€412.72
Pay now€196.28
Pay at property€216.44

The same fee-display rule from Deal details carries through here.

Confirm cancellation
Booking cancellation email

· via email

Hi {FirstName},
This booking was cancelled. We sent the email to {email}.

Booking ID: 675919442573866

Book again

Every screen the price touches, mobile and desktop, with the funnel's own fee-display rule turned into a question you can answer yourself.

03

What changed: side A and side B

The product owner and the data scientist wrote up the test. I drew the two sides, so anyone who had missed every meeting could see what changed.

Side A is the booking as it was, and side B the change, on the same journey from room selection to checkout. Switch between them and the change comes down to three things: the fee gets its name back, what you pay now is separated from what you pay at the hotel, and a sentence says who collects it.

Room selection

More than one night, or more than one room?

1 night, 1 room
You found the best deal
FH FindHotel
CLP 59,803CLP 51,381

Resort Tower Two Queen …

14% off Partially refundable rate
Deal details

Compared with 2 other sites No changes

Hotels
Resort Tower Two Queen …

Non-refundable rate
Booking
Resort Tower Two Queen …

Non-refundable rate

Nightly price including taxes and fees

CLP 59,803

CLP 51,381 Nightly price including taxes and fees

Price details 14% off

1 night x 1 room
CLP 17,540.28
Taxes and fees
CLP 2,699.71
Due at property
CLP 31,140.86
Resort fee
CLP 31,109.12
Total
CLP 51,380.86
Total
CLP 51,328.48
2 nights, 2 rooms
You found the best deal
FH FindHotel
CLP 74,531CLP 62,031

Resort Tower Two Queen …

17% off Partially refundable rate
Deal details

Compared with 2 other sites No changes

Hotels
Resort Tower Two Queen …
CLP 74,507
Non-refundable rate
Booking
Resort Tower Two Queen …
CLP 74,531
Non-refundable rate

Nightly price per room including taxes and fees

CLP 74,531

CLP 62,031 Nightly price per room including taxes and fees

Price details 17% off

2 nights x 2 rooms
CLP 26,773.45 average per night per room
CLP 107,093.81
Taxes and fees
CLP 4,116.28 average per night per room
CLP 16,465.10
Due at property
CLP 124,563.46
Resort fee
CLP 31,109.12 average per night per room
CLP 124,436.48
Total
CLP 248,122.37
Total
CLP 247,869.44
Checkout

Is the guest’s currency different from the property’s?

Nothing tells the guest which currency they will pay in at the property.

Pay now
$25.79
Pay at property
$39.68

Pay at property amount will be collected by the property in the local currency.

Is anything due at the property?

More than one night, or more than one room?

1 night, 1 room

1 King Bed, Nonsmoking

Non-refundable rate

Price details 5% off

1 night x 1 room
CLP 41,437.44
Taxes and fees
CLP 12,690.22
Total price
with taxes & fees
CLP 54,127.66
($68.97)
Total
CLP 54,127.66
Total saving
CLP 2,862.46
Total saving
CLP 2,862.46

The price is converted to show you the approximate cost in CLP. You’ll pay in USD.

The price is converted to show you the approximate cost in CLP. You’ll pay now in USD ($68.97).

2 nights, 2 rooms

1 King Bed, Nonsmoking

Non-refundable rate

Price details 5% off

2 nights x 2 rooms
CLP 41,437.44 per night per room
CLP 165,749.76
Taxes and fees
CLP 12,643.13 per night per room
CLP 50,572.51
Total price
with taxes & fees
CLP 216,322.27
($275.64)
Total
CLP 216,322.27
Total saving
CLP 11,633.11
Total saving
CLP 11,633.11

The price is converted to show you the approximate cost in CLP. You’ll pay in USD.

The price is converted to show you the approximate cost in CLP. You’ll pay now in USD ($275.64).

More than one night, or more than one room?

1 night, 1 room

Resort Tower Two Queen Room

Partially refundable rate

Price details 14% off

1 night x 1 room
CLP 17,540.28
Taxes and fees
CLP 2,699.71
Due now
CLP 20,239.99
Due at property
CLP 31,109.12
Resort fee
CLP 31,109.12
Total price
with taxes & fees
CLP 51,380.86
($65.47)
Total
CLP 51,328.48
Total saving
CLP 8,422.44
Total saving
CLP 8,474.82
Pay now
CLP 20,219.36
Pay at property
CLP 31,109.12

The price is converted to show you the approximate cost in CLP. You’ll pay in USD.

The price is converted to show you the approximate cost in CLP. You’ll pay now in USD ($25.79). Pay at property amount will be collected by the property in the local currency.

2 nights, 2 rooms

Resort Tower Two Queen Room

Partially refundable rate

Price details 17% off

2 nights x 2 rooms
CLP 26,773.45 per night per room
CLP 107,093.81
Taxes and fees
CLP 4,112.08 per night per room
CLP 16,465.10
Due now
CLP 123,558.91
Due at property
CLP 124,436.48
Resort fee
CLP 31,109.12 per night per room
CLP 124,436.48
Total price
with taxes & fees
CLP 248,122.37
($316.16)
Total
CLP 247,869.44
Total saving
CLP 50,001.57
Total saving
CLP 50,254.50
Pay now
CLP 123,432.96
Pay at property
CLP 124,436.48

The price is converted to show you the approximate cost in CLP. You’ll pay in USD.

The price is converted to show you the approximate cost in CLP. You’ll pay now in USD ($157.44). Pay at property amount will be collected by the property in the local currency.

Once the developers had something unreleased, I tested the scenarios agreed for that sprint by hand, so that whether everything was covered did not depend on anyone's memory.

Deep dive

Two recordings from real travellers

Two videos

Once it was live, the question became what people actually do with it. FullStory records real sessions and filters them by behaviour or by country. Anything worth keeping, a bug, an idea or a habit nobody predicted, went into a document.

Two of those sessions: an American traveller on side B of the test, going from room selection to checkout, and a traveller in Japan opening the price breakdown of a room.

United States, room selection through to checkout, on the B side of the test

Japan, opening the price breakdown from the room selection page

Prototype

The prototype itself

The scenario selector, offering a one night one room stay and choice of World, French or American user

Scenario selector

The Figma prototype, in three versions: a traveller anywhere in the world, a French traveller and an American one. Pick one to see how the total price is built for them.

Prototype

The Figma prototype the concept was tested on, one flow shown for three locales.

Conclusion

What five weeks of traffic said

+3.5%

Conversion, for travellers outside the United States, over a five-week test.

Taxes-included markets moved most

The effect was sharpest where people already expect a displayed price to contain the tax. What we had folded in was not tax at all: it was the accommodation fees sitting beside it.

Desktop up, mobile down

Desktop traffic converted better. Mobile traffic converted slightly worse, on the same change, in the same weeks.

A week ahead, better

Bookings made about a week in advance improved. Last-minute bookings were slightly worse off, which is the pattern you would expect if reading takes time somebody does not have.

We designed this for American travellers arriving from Google hotel ads, the largest group on the site. But Findhotel is a global company, so the change went to travellers everywhere, and the gain came from outside the United States.

Where the price shown already includes tax, travellers expect the number on the tile to be the number they pay. When that expectation broke, fixing it was worth a lot. In the United States, where tax is added at the end, travellers expect the opposite, so there was less to fix.

Mobile converted slightly worse. Every charge on its own line is one more line, and a phone has the least room for it.

What came next

By December 2020 the work had become a set of rules: one map of how to show a price at each stage, from the search results through room selection and deal details to checkout. Four boards, one per stage.

This is also where the two Findhotel projects on this site meet. The bottom of that checkout board is a choice between paying now and paying at the property, and giving somebody that choice properly is its own case study. Naming what the property collects is what made it possible to offer.

Lessons

The winners refused the question
Two of the eight platforms answered both questions the same way in every market: they showed the base rate and the total together, instead of choosing one. I had built the study around a yes or a no, and the best answer was neither. Next time I will leave room for answers I did not expect.
Copy matters, and it is cheap to change
The words on a price have a large effect on how a traveller experiences it, and they are the easiest part to change. Calling an amount due at the property a resort fee costs no engineering, and it tells the traveller what they are paying for.
Clarity has a screen size
Desktop went up and mobile went down on the same release. A detailed price is easy to show on a wide screen and hard on a narrow one. I would now design the breakdown separately for mobile instead of letting it reflow.